Top
Get science ideas & lessons right in your inbox!

Grading Interactive Notebooks




Sometimes I hear people say that they do not use interactive notebooks because the grading is so difficult.   I would agree that it can be challenging but I have devised a few ways to keep it manageable. 


First of all I would give students a very clear rubric of what you are looking for.   A sample rubric will be included later in this post.

I have the students select an area of best work and write a reflection on that.   Then have them tab the following sections which makes it easier for me to grade. 

Reflection for Interactive Notebook
Please tab the following sections
-Table of contents
-Best Work Activity
-Reflection including rubric
 This is the reflection I am having them complete.   It could be modified easily for the specific needs of the students.  
Paragraph One
Choose 1 assignment (topic or section) from the notebook that represents your BEST WORK and write a paragraph about it. For elementary and secondary students you may want to have them select one entry from the unit you are assessing.    Please state the specific reasons for why you chose the items and why they represent your best work.    Please tab this section.    
Ideas to write about include:
  • What you learned
  • How you learned
  • What aspects of the work were high quality
  • What you would do differently and why
  • What makes you proud of the work
  • What made the activity worthwhile
  • For pre service teachers I have them also comment on what they have learned about science
You should also write about how the assignment chosen demonstrates your skills as a student. For example, skills you might write about are that the assignments show that you are organized, you are good at analyzing, you were very thoroughcreative, your information was very accurate, you made connections from one assignment to another, and so on.
*Make sure that you cite specific examples from the assignments you chose.

Paragraph Two
Evaluate your notebook according to the rubric.  How would you score yourself?   What could be improved? 
Here is the rubric I am currently using for my pre-service teachers:  

Criteria:
Complete Table of Contents
All Entries Included
Articulation of Learning
Notebook Includes at least Five Foldable
Notebook Includes at least 3 Thinking Maps of Graphic Organizers
Includes illustrations, graphs and charts
Reflection included and there is a response to all of the prompts

Paragraph Three
For pre-service teachers: General thoughts, feelings and opinions about interactive notebooks…Will you use them as a teacher?  


For Elementary and High School, I would suggest keeping notebooks in the class.   They should stay in class so that they are always available when needed.   I would collect them once or twice during a unit, glance at all the entries and then grade one assignment more deeply.

You can select the item ahead of time that you will be grading or you can have the students select the item for grading.  In other words, do not try to grade everything.  Some items can just be checked and given credit for participation.  You can assign points as you feel appropriate.  

In Class Science Notebook Rubric
Incomplete
Completed
Table of Contents is Accurate and Includes All Assignments
Concepts and Learning Articulated
Reflection Included on Best Entry for the Unit
All Entries Included
Two Foldables Included for this Unit
Two Graphs or Diagrams included in this Unit
You may find my products for interactive notebooks useful
Please follow this blog by clicking the g+ button under my photo or by selecting the follow by email option.

Here is a freebie you can use in your classroom.




    Classroom freebies

    Comments

    1. I love reading about the grading. I started notebooks this year but was intimidated by the table of contents. I teach science and social studies to 4th graders. The science part went pretty well.

    Leave a Reply

    Start Here

    I am so impressed with this unit which manages to be distance learning and hands-on at the same time.  Really well thought out and engaging activities that allow students to practice each of the eight Science and Engineering Practices.  Really no prep for me!

     
    Science and Engineering Practices Distance Education Unit

    Tina S

    Teaching Science with Lynda R. Williams
    5
    2016-05-03T18:05:39-06:00

    Tina S

    I am so impressed with this unit which manages to be distance learning and hands-on at the same time.  Really well thought out and engaging activities that allow students to practice each of the eight Science and Engineering Practices.  Really no prep for me!   Science and Engineering Practices Distance Education Unit
    The elephant article was excellent but I also thought the lab on dissecting a flower was broken down so easily, even telling me where to get inexpensive flowers!  This resource helped me teach this challenging standard in an engaging way.  Worth every penny!

     
    Structure and Function NGSS 4-LS1-1 and 4-LS1-2

    Richard S

    Teaching Science with Lynda R. Williams
    5
    2016-05-03T18:07:52-06:00

    Richard S

    The elephant article was excellent but I also thought the lab on dissecting a flower was broken down so easily, even telling me where to get inexpensive flowers!  This resource helped me teach this challenging standard in an engaging way.  Worth every penny!   Structure and Function NGSS 4-LS1-1 and 4-LS1-2
    As always, Lynda provides perfect alignment with the standards.

     
    Age of the Earth and Geologic Time Scale NGSS MS ESS1-4

    Sharon M

    Teaching Science with Lynda R. Williams
    5
    2016-05-03T18:24:44-06:00

    Sharon M

    As always, Lynda provides perfect alignment with the standards.   Age of the Earth and Geologic Time Scale NGSS MS ESS1-4
    Thank you so much for creating this resource! It is such a fun and engaging activity for my students, especially during distance learning.

     
    Honey Bee Digital Escape Distance Learning

    Expedition Fourth

    Teaching Science with Lynda R. Williams
    2020-11-03T20:44:55-07:00

    Expedition Fourth

    Thank you so much for creating this resource! It is such a fun and engaging activity for my students, especially during distance learning.   Honey Bee Digital Escape Distance Learning
    My students loved this unit. I was able to present different elements of it throughout the month. It is hard to find interesting non-fictional, age-appropriate text for my students that they will enjoy. This was a great unit that aligned well for my students who have very different goals within the same group.

     
    Compare and Contrast Two Texts on Reindeer

    Heidi J

    Teaching Science with Lynda R. Williams
    2020-11-03T20:45:49-07:00

    Heidi J

    My students loved this unit. I was able to present different elements of it throughout the month. It is hard to find interesting non-fictional, age-appropriate text for my students that they will enjoy. This was a great unit that aligned well for my students who have very different goals within the same group.   Compare and Contrast Two Texts on Reindeer
    5
    3
    Teaching Science with Lynda R. Williams